to be honest, i think that both of those drives are great, and its really a toss up. for only $10 more the seagate is probably quieter, but idk how much you would really notice it
__________________
CPU || e8400
RAM || 4GB corsair xms2 pc6400 800mhz
HDD || 2x WD Raptor 150GB 2x WD 500GB
MBO || EVGA 680i SE
GPU || Evga 8800GT Superclocked w/ Accelero
PSU || Silverstone 750 watt
Case|| Antec p182
|