The plot continues...
Not sure what the hell is going on, but how is this for a Christmas Eve treat:
I was pointed in the direction of Vincent Aguilar at NewEgg who spoke with me Tuesday evening...ask a few simple questions and said we would clear this up by the end of the day or Wednesday morning at the latest. Refunding my money would be the easiest option he said.
When we spoke on Wednesday, a few of the things he said caught my ear. He had been under the mistaken impression (and after rereading my email I know I was clear...not sure how he was confused) that I was insisting I was shipped the wrong item to begin with. I was not...from the beginning I said I received the right item, shipped it back to NewEgg and after doing so, the RMA inspector said the processor wasn't the item they originally shipped...that it was substituted for another. Once I corrected him and asked him to reread my email while I was on the phone, he said he'd need to call me back. He said that the box was tampered with in transit from UPS.
Now I overnighted the box...so the liklihood of some mid-west UPS worker saying, "WOW! A NewEgg damaged item with an RMA tag! I'll open it up and steal a $1500 processor out of it and substitute this Intel QX9700 I custom modified with additional pieces and continue shipping it to Newegg!" This is clearly a silly suggestion...overnighting a box doesn't leave a lot of "sitting around time".
In due diligence I called UPS and spoke with my preferred customer care & account manager (as luckily for me, we have a corporate UPS account to handle things like this.) They opened a damage/trouble ticket and arranged for an onsite inspection of this claim at NewEgg.
Christmas Eve:
Vincent called me back Christmas Eve and said they would not honor a refund or replace the item. I reminded him that I had been honest and corrected his misunderstanding of the situation. If I had been dishonest and pretended that he was correct, I would have my money back by now (perhaps I should've lied from the beginning???)
He agreed to send over pictures of the item, a write up of the denial of the RMA & would meet with the UPS rep on Monday.
Today - 12/29:
I followed up with UPS and interestingly enough, Vincent called UPS after speaking with me to change the on-site inspection to a pick-up and inspection. Meaning UPS would pick up this item that doesn't belong to me, look it over and return it to me. I changed this back, emailed Vincent & requested what he had promised me last week: pictures of this item & in-writing why they were denying the claim. UPS will be visiting them tomorrow...by why do I feel like I am being given the run around and NewEgg is trying to stick me with this piece of crap used item I didn't return and pocket my $1500???
Next Course of Action:
Re-email the CEO, thank him for wishing me a Merry Christmas and let me know his employees did not "take care of me". Call Alex Villarino and let him know that if we can't come to a resolution, I'll do whatever I need to from a consumer standpoint to share this story with as many consumer advocacy groups as possible, buy NewEggStinks.com and create a forum to galvanize the thousands of consumers that I have found online who have stiffed by them, file a complaint with a better business beareau and inform my bank of fraud on my account.