Windows Vista/7 (preferably 7) for me. Ever try installing Win XP on a laptop? The dam*n OS wouldn't even recognize your ethernet/graphics adapter. And, if you only had one computer and lack the ethernet & graphics drivers while re-installing WinXP, you're screwed, graphics- and net-wise, because there would be no way for you to download those drivers (read: ethernet non-functional). With Vista, at least the ethernet works on re-install, so you could go online and download the proper drivers, instead of the Windows default.
I've installed Windows XP on several laptops for different people. These laptops ranged from 7-2 years old. Each time XP found functioning drivers within the OS for ethernet, audio, graphics, etc.
Windows XP was great but too many people are hanging onto it. Let it go people
. I suppose you might as well wait until Win7 is released now.
I'm surprised how well Vista's doing... I guess I need to try Vista Business more, but Home Premium has been nothing but trouble for me...
As for my personal vote, I said XP Pro. I feel that was the last OS that still left a fair amount of power to the user. Vista is nothing but a bunch of pointless wizards, usless UAC, and simplified lists of icons (IE the new control pannel) that make things even more complicated to use. While some of these things can be disabled, many things can't be, or can't be in Windows 7. So... XP was the best, Vista was the beginning of the end
I simply don't have any trouble with Vista Home Premium. Have you installed it on older hardware? Even then I've installed it on my older desktop that must be about 4-5 years old now. It was a high end game rig for it's time though and has 4GB's of ram, a decent GPU etc. I have it installed on my new game rig and also on a laptop I bought nearly a year ago. I use two of my computers daily (newest game rig and laptop) and they run superbly. UAC is simply junk I agree, you can disable it as you said, so I don't see a problem there. The new control panel... well I don't know because I use "Classic View". Vista is heavily bloated which is just dumb. But still, it has many great features. If you have a decent rig then there should be no problems really.
Windows XP was my favorite. I hated all Windows OS's until XP. I ran Linux actually until the release of XP. Although I always had a Windows OS as a duel boot for games. I always longed for some eye candy with Windows, and apps like Windowblinds and others did not cut it with me. Vista got released and I fell in love with it. I feel it's very unfortunate that so many had such a bad experience with it and gave up on it. I always felt that if people were willing to upgrade to Vista, then they should be willing to pay for some decent hardware as well. I mean any modern machine will run it. Memory has got fairly cheap and HD's are getting larger. My oldest desktop runs it perfectly and that was built at least 3'ish years before Vista's release.
Oh and Windows7 is basically Vista upgraded. One thing is for sure, I'm going to miss Vista when Win7 is released. I'll surely switch early only because I always need to have what's most recent. Why then would I miss Vista if Win7 is Vista upgraded? Well I'm not so sure about that Win7 taskbar... Looks a bit wierd to me, I've always liked the one in Vista.