Mac user is doing a build, critique me please?

I just realized I forgot to define how I'm using it...
Lots of media stuff. Heavy photo editing/manipulating. HD video handling, and a TON of music. Handling multitasking and heavy 2D rendering is a must. 3d rendering moderately important. Photoshop CS4 will take advantage if it's there, but that's about it. I do VERY little, if not zero PC gaming. I'm a Mac user, remember, and I don't miss not having the pc game access. I have a 360 and PS3 for that.

Just to play devil's advocate here. If you are willing to spend $2-3k on a desktop and don't care about gaming, a Mac Pro will whoop any desktop you can build. It has dual xeon processors, which will whomp the crap out of any desktop processor in pure performance.

Go ahead and try to build a dual xeon processor desktop spec for spec compared to a Mac Pro and you won't find any one cheaper, and it will out perform all other desktops in what you want to do.

Now, if you aren't putting a heavy of enough load on your desktop to justify the cost of having Xeon's then yeah, sure building your own may be better. I just want to point that out, that any dual xeon would kick the crap out of any i7 or C2D or AMD processor setup.

It all comes down to what you actually need versus how much you want to spend. If you need the power of dual Xeon processors then a Mac Pro is quite good for the price. I have compared them to Dell workstations that have the same hardware and the Mac Pro is typically the same price or slightly cheaper.

I have yet to even try to build a dual Xeon desktop from scratch and find it anywhere near as cheap as a Mac or a Dell.

Just food for thought is all. Especially if gaming is not a factor.
 
Just to play devil's advocate here. If you are willing to spend $2-3k on a desktop and don't care about gaming, a Mac Pro will whoop any desktop you can build. It has dual xeon processors, which will whomp the crap out of any desktop processor in pure performance.

Go ahead and try to build a dual xeon processor desktop spec for spec compared to a Mac Pro and you won't find any one cheaper, and it will out perform all other desktops in what you want to do.

Now, if you aren't putting a heavy of enough load on your desktop to justify the cost of having Xeon's then yeah, sure building your own may be better. I just want to point that out, that any dual xeon would kick the crap out of any i7 or C2D or AMD processor setup.

It all comes down to what you actually need versus how much you want to spend. If you need the power of dual Xeon processors then a Mac Pro is quite good for the price. I have compared them to Dell workstations that have the same hardware and the Mac Pro is typically the same price or slightly cheaper.

I have yet to even try to build a dual Xeon desktop from scratch and find it anywhere near as cheap as a Mac or a Dell.

Just food for thought is all. Especially if gaming is not a factor.

Yeahm but I'm really not willing to spend that much, so... :D

I assure you, in a perfect world, I'd have gone for a Mac, but the price vs. value comparison on the desktops just didn't stack up for me. I see what you're saying though, those are blazing machines.

I ended up splitting the difference on the power supplies, and ended up going for this one:
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16817139005

My final price came out to be ~~1150 with shipping, and I also picked up Vista Ultimate 64. Should be fun getting it, thanks much for the input. I'll post back when I have the stuff/any issues.
 
The Mac Pro with Dual Xeon's starts at $3,300.00
http://store.apple.com/us/configure/MB535LL/A?mco=NDE4NDIyMQ

Complete overkill if you ask me, for any practical use.

No, they start at $2400. The one that starts at $3200 is faster ram, faster bus, etc. It is a higher end model.

These are made for serious business, so yes overkill for your average user. However, if you want killer performance in 2D/3D rendering, video loading and editing, and number crunching the Xeon will out perform all other desktops hands down.

if you are going to surf the web and burn CDs then yes waaaaay over kill. It depends on your needs and what you are willing to spend.
 
No, they start at $2400. The one that starts at $3200 is faster ram, faster bus, etc. It is a higher end model...

Bodaggit was referring to the fact that the $3200 is the dual quad-core Xeon. The $2400 is the single Quad - which is still a beast...

Edit: Where did you get the fast ram, faster bus specs? I thought both the new single and dual Quads were identical in that department - except that the dual Quad has eight RAM slots and supports more memory overall. The main difference is just whether or not it is a 4-core or 8-core machine.


These are made for serious business, so yes overkill for your average user. However, if you want killer performance in 2D/3D rendering, video loading and editing, and number crunching the Xeon will out perform all other desktops hands down.

if you are going to surf the web and burn CDs then yes waaaaay over kill. It depends on your needs and what you are willing to spend.
Exactly! :):good:
 
Last edited:
I ended up splitting the difference on the power supplies, and ended up going for this one:
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16817139005

My final price came out to be ~~1150 with shipping, and I also picked up Vista Ultimate 64. Should be fun getting it, thanks much for the input. I'll post back when I have the stuff/any issues.

Good choice Justin. Enjoy the build!

Putting it together is part of the fun... ;)

Darn good price for an i7 build. Did that cost include Vista as well?
 
Bodaggit was referring to the fact that the $3200 is the dual quad-core Xeon. The $2400 is the single Quad - which is still a beast...

Edit: Where did you get the fast ram, faster bus specs? I thought both the new single and dual Quads were identical in that department - except that the dual Quad has eight RAM slots and supports more memory overall. The main difference is just whether or not it is a 4-core or 8-core machine.

I had not been to the apple store in a bit, and have not studied up on their new models. I was wrong, that is the difference between single and dual processors. Where as the last revision the entry dual processor started at about 2800, so they did upgrade some things to incorporate a bit of a higher starting cost. That is what I was getting at.

yeah I just built a new PC last fall, and I am pretty much a Mac user for the most part, but I didn't want or need the power of a Mac Pro and didn't want an all-in-one desktop either. So I see the pros and cons of building your own PC. Vista however, sucks monkey butt. Almost all Java based apps I run on Vista seem to love to memory leak, and eat a crap ton of memory.
 
I had not been to the apple store in a bit, and have not studied up on their new models. I was wrong, that is the difference between single and dual processors. Where as the last revision the entry dual processor started at about 2800, so they did upgrade some things to incorporate a bit of a higher starting cost. That is what I was getting at.

yeah I just built a new PC last fall, and I am pretty much a Mac user for the most part, but I didn't want or need the power of a Mac Pro and didn't want an all-in-one desktop either. So I see the pros and cons of building your own PC. Vista however, sucks monkey butt. Almost all Java based apps I run on Vista seem to love to memory leak, and eat a crap ton of memory.

No problem. I was wondering if you were thinking of the prior models. You were spot on in that regard. :)

I am with you as I am currently Mac-less my self. I miss it, too. My Powerbooks used to be my Swiss Army knife...

Were you able to get in on the Windows 7 beta? I am actually loving it compared to Vista.
 
No problem. I was wondering if you were thinking of the prior models. You were spot on in that regard. :)

I am with you as I am currently Mac-less my self. I miss it, too. My Powerbooks used to be my Swiss Army knife...

Were you able to get in on the Windows 7 beta? I am actually loving it compared to Vista.

I actually have a Macbook Pro 2nd Gen and a G5 dual 2.5 desktop, plus 4 Mac Minis, iMac 2,5, and a G5 desktop at work.

I only have two PCs the rest are Macs for me.
 
Sorry to say, but the Mac Pro's that come with Dual Xeon Processors start at $3,300.00.

Check the link and the specs again...

Yes that was clarified several posts ago, I was going off older models and older prices as I had not checked the apple store in the past few months.
 
I actually have a Macbook Pro 2nd Gen and a G5 dual 2.5 desktop, plus 4 Mac Minis, iMac 2,5, and a G5 desktop at work.

I only have two PCs the rest are Macs for me.


Lucky man... :)

I've gone from an all Mac workplace to an all Windows workplace in the last few years (different jobs). I've sold off all my newer Macs to family members who could really use them, too. My next Mac purchase, provided I can get the budget to balance, is going be one of the new Mini's. I've waiting for Apple to update those buggers. It's going to go right under my TV.

I have a veritable Macintosh museum in storage though. Most of them work, too!
 
That's why I put a link in the post when I made that statement.

yeah and I already corrected myself, so drop it. It was a simple mistake.

Lucky man...

I've gone from an all Mac workplace to an all Windows workplace in the last few years (different jobs). I've sold off all my newer Macs to family members who could really use them, too. My next Mac purchase, provided I can get the budget to balance, is going be one of the new Mini's. I've waiting for Apple to update those buggers. It's going to go right under my TV.

I have a veritable Macintosh museum in storage though. Most of them work, too!

When you manage 6 million dollars of Apple equipment they tend to give you apple equipment to manage it with.
 
Last edited:
lol since i'm so bored I just filled out the custom build for Mac Pro to make it expensive, it ended up $22,585.90 lol
 
When you manage 6 million dollars of Apple equipment they tend to give you apple equipment to manage it with.

Aye, I would hope so! :D


lol since i'm so bored I just filled out the custom build for Mac Pro to make it expensive, it ended up $22,585.90 lol

There was a time a few years ago where the maximum configuration for RAM was over $60K. Apple has the habit of using high-end parts and charging well above market for them. This isn't far off from other manufacturers either - Dell and HP also charge premiums for simple upgrades. For years I have purchased stock systems from Apple then upgraded the RAM and HDD myself for much less.
 
I have had apple sales engineers tell me, if I max out the RAM on any server, the server will be free.

Truth be told ECC RAM is really that expensive and the mark up on hardware really is not ever that much. All the money in technology is made from accessories and software, not in hardware sales at all. Kind of like money isn't really made from the sale of a car, it is the service of the car where they make all their money at.

ECC RAM even bought form the cheapest vendor you can find on line is still going to be ungodly expensive. The thing is ECC memory comes in tiers, and there is unbuffered to fully buffered. So the price ranges are way out there. Apple of course, only wants to carry the highest end RAM possible.
 
Back
Top