Mate, you can just say you were wrong. If I were in the minority, how is it that it is the best sellig game in history? The game is uber successful on all measures. Time to concede. Your claims around taste, is something altogether differnt and subjective. And in terms of the comments, only people with an axe to grind generally comment, like reviews on hardware, hardly reputable. A bit like the point of this whole thread...
I speculated what was actually meant based on how the company acted in the past whilst there was no evidence for what they were saying, but now that they have some sort of figures, I was incorrect and it is based on units. Does that mean I change my mind because numbers = better? Of course not, anyone can buy something, but it takes the product to be good to enjoy it.
For how it is the best selling game, this sort of sums it up:
Dont think it is really an achievement for Treyarch. Think we all knew it would sell well. Slap “Call of Duty” on anything, and anyone could sell it!
As for the comments, what you are saying is "if your opinion is negative or different to mine it doesn't count for jack"?
I think the game is a joke, I think it is a remake of every other CoD game, I think that people bought it on the hope that it would be good as most of the previous games had been, but realised that the gameplay was stale, the maps were unoriginal, the sounds were appalling, the single player was just an interactive movie unless they played on veteran, and even then it wasn't much of a challenge, it was buggy, and overall, it was just the same old stuff as last time, but done worse.
You harp on about facts, and the facts about opinions are there, plain and simple, if everywhere you look the majority are saying it was bad, guess what that generally means - the majority think that it is bad. You can't just selectively pick what evidence you want to use, unless there is a good reason, and saying people only post negative things, clearly isn't true when you have people commenting on certain things saying this is the best ever or I can't wait for this
=EDIT=
oh, and you might want to check out the user score on metacritic too, just like everything else on the net from the people that actually play the game, it backs up exactly what I am saying
http://www.metacritic.com/game/pc/call-of-duty-black-ops