Please help me decide which to purchase

C

Creampuff

New Member
Dell UltraSharp U2311H 23" or HP ZR22w 21.5-inch S-IPS LCD Monitor



(HP) much more expensive + slightly smaller.
(Dell) Cheaper + wider.

Both within Budget.
Monitor use for Graphics & CAD modelling, rendering. :)
Please do advice which is a better product to purchase, as i don't really see any big difference with the two.:)

THANK YOU FOR YOUR HELP :D
 
I used an UltraSharp at work and the picture was amazing, noticeably different than other monitors. Having said that I have no experience with the HP. I do a lot of CAD work, and generally find that the bigger the screen the better/easier it is to work.

Hope that helps, Doug.
 
@ Mihir,

Thanks for the feedback Mihir :D
Hmm if this is the case with Dell's i need to check if HP's have this issue either, i google an article saying that almost all LCDs suffer at least a small amount of backlight bleed because the opacity of LCD panels, but i wouldn't want my monitor with such symptom.
So did your warranty with Dell manage to replace the old with a new one ?


@ dug,

Thanks for the feedback dug. :D
It's good to hear that Dell's monitor works well for you.
Did you happen to experience any bleeding issues as mentioned by Mihir?
 
I did not buy the monitor because I discovered there was a bleeding issue.
The monitor in the LAB computer has an HP monitor which is a P-VA panel and I must say the monitor is beyond amazing,never had any experience with the one you posted but was considering the same when I was out for a monitor but since it was expensive in India, so did not go for it.

The monitor I posted is also amazing
http://anonymouse.org/cgi-bin/anon-...com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16824002578
And not that heavy on your pocket either and NEC makes really awesome panels. :D
 
Creampuff said:
@ dug,

Thanks for the feedback dug. :D
It's good to hear that Dell's monitor works well for you.
Did you happen to experience any bleeding issues as mentioned by Mihir?
Click to expand...

No, but I'm not sure what model it was I was using. I was just referring to various UltraSharp monitors around the office.
 
@Mihir,

I see, i don't think i can get a NEC here, not too sure...
Nevertheless i shall keep my option open, and maybe explore more.
Thanks for the suggestion Mihir. :)


@Dug,
I see i see,
No problem Doug, Thanks for the feedback too :)

- Have a nice day people ! -
 
I just went from a widescreen 22" HP monitor to a 1707FPt Ultrasharp monitor.
I would go with the Ultrasharp, the quality is much better, especially the color, plus the monitor itself juts looks amazing!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top