which one is more realistic

[Mustardsky]

well i had about 300 dollars and i was thinking of getting rock band or guitar hero but i want the one that is more realistic which one is the more realistic one by realistic i mean gameplay which one has a more realistic guitar

 

[HumanMage]

I've played both, and thought rock band was more realistic. It's the perfect multiplayer game as well. The guitar that comes with Rock Band is a lot worse than the one provided by Guitar Hero though.

 

[Mustardsky]

why and which guitar is more realistic

 

[Cleric7x9]

um, neither of them are realistic. its a video game, there are 5 buttons. rockband is easier than guitarhero, but arguably more fun. i think the rockband guitar is a POS tho, the feel of the guitarhero guitar is much better

 

[Quiltface]

yeah its a game not even close to realistic... the most realistic controller would have to have 150 buttons on it that you have change periodically and get them in tune.... plus the controller would have to weigh about 8 pounds and you wouldnt be judged on randomly using a trem.

 

[Mustardsky]

i have a few questions if get the guitar from rock band 2 can i get the disc of the rock band 1 from your prespective which has better songs the newer rock band or the newest guitar hero

 

[m0nk3ys1ms]

Wait and get Guitar Hero: World Tour.

 

[jdbennet]

Rock Band drum kit is awesome.

 

[gamerman4]

I still think Guitar Hero 2 has the best songs of the ones I played so far.

 

[Hyper_Kagome]

Guitar Hero 4 is to have drums, but differently set up than Rock Band's to give it a more authentic feel by giving their set up two cymbal pads that are raised higher than the others, similar to that of a drum set.

But... GH4 isn't out yet.