ur not going to be getting anything good for that amount of money. increase ur budget or ur not getting a good gpu. its as simple as that
I would look into getting a used 9600gso which is a g92 core 8800gts. I managed to pick on up on ebay for $50 shipped which, is an absolute steal. Considering a 9800gt (same thing) sells for over $100.
I was trying to stick with the ati radeon becuase of my motherboard and everything it seemed like ati radeon works the best but if you say that geforce will be good then I will get that.
I just thought it was recommended...
I am looking for something good so I would pay a little extra and get a good one but about $60 is my max. Which one out of those are better.