Hard Drive purchase assistance.

A

Altanore

New Member
I am planning on buying another hard drive since my 120GB drive is proving not to be enough space.

Anyway, I have my eyes on two drives...

firstly,

$165 Samsung 400GB 7200RPM 16MB SATA II

I found it surprising it was very cheap... I was thinking of getting two of these to get more space. However, I just want to make sure these hard drives are not low quality since the price seems very low. However, I believe Samsung is a good company.

If not that, I planned to purchase:

$439 Seagate Barracuda 7200.10 750GB 16MB SATA II

Course, with Samsung, I'd be getting more space for a cheaper price.. but the quality of their drives is what im concerned of.

Any suggestions?
Thanks :D
 
The reviews on the Samsung Spinpoint drives are very great, thats what I would go with. Also, with two drives you can run them in RAID for increased performance.
 
I've heard good stuff about Samsung drives, but the last one I used was a 3.2G(IE, a while back :P) so I don't have much experience on current drives.

Personally, I'd go with Western Digital. Out of all the drives I've had, they have been the most reliable and the fastest. However, if you only can get the two you mentioned, I'd get a pair of Samsung's, as monkeysims mentioned.
 
Hey, thanks for the reply's :)

I was thinking of western digital too since I know they are reliable. I found this:

$245 WD WD4000YR 400GB 16MB SATA Raid Edition

Could get two of those but they are much more expensive than the samsung drives and don't have SATA2 (Although I can't take advantage of SATA2 but will be useful in the future when I upgrade to a new motherboard).

Course, reliability certainly won't be a concern with this drive and looking at the reviews, it seems to out perform some of it's competitors. In the review, it was better than a Samsung P80 spinpoint but it was a 160GB version. I just might go ahead with the western digital. Afterall, it is a raid edition :D
 
Western Digitals are NOT reliable at ALL. As I mentioned in another thread, I am a former Western Digital Authorized Reseller. Former for a reason. The infamous click click click and the ever so bloody annoying wiping out of the MFT for no logical reason. Those drives are crap. I have RMAed more WD SE HDDs than any other manufacturer save for Fujitsu. Not only are they unreliable, they choke under heavy load. They are for light duty household use only.

If you are gung ho for Western Digital, you want either the RE or the Raptor. Both are enterprise level HDDs.

The Spinpoint is a good drive. It has done very well for itself and I have no problems recommending one. The Seagate is a very good drive as well. They made a name for themselves with their SCSI drives. Incidentally were you aware that Seagate bought out Maxtor for almost $2B back in May?
 
SirKenin said:
Western Digitals are NOT reliable at ALL. As I mentioned in another thread, I am a former Western Digital Authorized Reseller. Former for a reason. The infamous click click click and the ever so bloody annoying wiping out of the MFT for no logical reason. Those drives are crap. I have RMAed more WD SE HDDs than any other manufacturer save for Fujitsu. Not only are they unreliable, they choke under heavy load. They are for light duty household use only.

If you are gung ho for Western Digital, you want either the RE or the Raptor. Both are enterprise level HDDs.

The Spinpoint is a good drive. It has done very well for itself and I have no problems recommending one. The Seagate is a very good drive as well. They made a name for themselves with their SCSI drives. Incidentally were you aware that Seagate bought out Maxtor for almost $2B back in May?
Click to expand...

Yeah, I was in the middle of RMA'ing a drive when they were doing that and I called 1-800-2-MAXTOR and it said like "Welcome to Seagate Maxtor", and I was like, are Maxtor's gonna be better, or are Seagate's gonna be worse. From some of the things I've heard, I think Seagate's gotten worse.
 
Hmm interesting. I have one 80GB Western Digital HD in my old computer.. has been there for 3 years now and is still healthy and running strong. So is my current WD HD but it's only a year old. However, companies change overtime so maybe they have gotten worse?

Only thing that threw me off on the Samsung was the low price (course, the low price is great) but I wanted to know if it was cheap due to being built cheaply or that it's just a grand deal. Maybe i'll go samsung and use the extra money saved on a creative sound blaster X-Fi.
 
Odd... I've had about 7 Western Digital drives within the last couple years and none of them have failed. I've had about 8 Maxtor drives, and all of them have failed... I've had about 5 segate drives, and one of them failed... Plus there's the one Seagate I encounted at work that failed(brand new)
 
See, you can not take the word of anyone who has had a handful of drives. You have to take a larger sample size. I deal with WD every day and have done so since 1999. My sample size far exceeds several hundred units. Very easily. When I see more than 1/3 of them fail, that is far too much.

Sure, you'll get the kid who says "I have a WD and it works great". That's meaningless. Of course you are going to get people that have WDs that function well.

Look at the big picture.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top