HDD on new PC clicking, but SeaTools Diagnostic reports nothing wrong!? Please help!

azwebs

New Member
As I have posted before, my sister just bought a new PC. The HDD on the machine has been clicking ever since it was turned on.

I have finally managed to get SeaTools to run on the SeaGate drive (by changing BIOS settings from AHCI to IDE mode). I did a full diagnostic of the drive, which took just under 4 hours.

The drive passed the test, but is still clicking, more than ever. Is it broken, or is it just a very noisy HDD?

I don't want to have to start copying data back, and then finding out that it needs replacing. Thanks for any help anyone.
 
first be positive it is the drive... unplug the power to it and turn the pc on is a good way to tell.

If it still clicks i would replace it. better safe than sorry.
 
I can't unplug the power to it, it's a new machine. If I open it, it invalidates the warranty. However, SeaTools does posess something called an Acoustic Test which can put the drive into mandatory idle (by cutting the power). During this time, the PC is perfectly silent apart from the fans hum. You then click a button to spin the drive up, and the clicking and whirring starts again!

I would like to be better safe than sorry, but seeing as their is no proven problem with the drive, will PC World replace it under warranty, or will I have to void it, and replace it myself?

I would hope they'll do it. Going to find some music to put on now, the clicking is beginning to deafen me.
 
assuming pc world is the place you bought it from... they should... bring it up there and they should make a decision on what to do.
 
The clicking is getting so annoying! I'm gonna have to sign in on my main in a minute, or this PC is going to die.

Look, I found an appropriate picture (not exactly what I wanted, but yeah).

Computer276.jpg


Thanks for the advice Quiltface.
 
NOOOOOO DONT DO THAT! THATS THE MONITOR, THAT WONT FIX THE CLICKING AT ALL!

haha no problem

Hahaha. Would've used a tower, but I couldn't find a picture - might take my own, depends on how today turns out!

Thanks for the help Quiltface.
 
Last edited:
Are you sure it will void the warranty to pop it open? Most major brands (Dell, HP, etc), now allow you to service most components without voiding the warranty. Unless, of course, there is warranty sticker on the case that you would have to tear to open it.

Either way, it is most certainly the hard drive the would be making the click anyway. I suppose that it could be a fan or even the CD drive, but it is probably the hard drive. Clicking occurs when the read/write arm on a hard drive is moving further than it should, either due to wear, abuse, or manufacturer defect, and is usually shortly followed by complete hard drive failure.

You should call the tech support line for the brand of the computer. If you're lucky and you get a competent representative, they should recognize the problem and repair the computer free of charge. If you're unlucky, they might not want to repair it, because technically it is still functioning as it should. If that happens, you might have to just wait until the hard drive fails (I would just leave the PC on 24/7 to wear the hard drive down).

Either way, it should be replaced under warranty... just make sure you get all important data off of it before it fails.
 
Are you sure it will void the warranty to pop it open? Most major brands (Dell, HP, etc), now allow you to service most components without voiding the warranty. Unless, of course, there is warranty sticker on the case that you would have to tear to open it.

Either way, it is most certainly the hard drive the would be making the click anyway. I suppose that it could be a fan or even the CD drive, but it is probably the hard drive. Clicking occurs when the read/write arm on a hard drive is moving further than it should, either due to wear, abuse, or manufacturer defect, and is usually shortly followed by complete hard drive failure.

You should call the tech support line for the brand of the computer. If you're lucky and you get a competent representative, they should recognize the problem and repair the computer free of charge. If you're unlucky, they might not want to repair it, because technically it is still functioning as it should. If that happens, you might have to just wait until the hard drive fails (I would just leave the PC on 24/7 to wear the hard drive down).

Either way, it should be replaced under warranty... just make sure you get all important data off of it before it fails.

Thanks for all the information. I will definitely check the status of the warranty there, because I have another hard drive I can test. I'm sure it's not another component, because if you read my post above, I ran an Acoustic Test (cut power to the drive, wait 30 seconds, and spin up again). Is silent during the 30 seconds, and then clicks more than ever.

Due to this being my 7th malfunctioning PC World product in under 2 months, I don't see that they're gonna give me too much trouble in servicing or replacing the product - it just depends on whether you get to speak to someone that knows what they're talking about.

Anyway, thanks everyone. I'm gonna ring and see who I get this time. Thanks again.

EDIT: No warranty label, but I'll ring to be sure - or check their website. Thanks.
 
Take it back!

Not a bad idea, but they don't have any more. I think they're either being discontinued, or their store is just not getting any any more. I know the Curry's Ashford store (same parent company) have sold their display model and discontinued the product. Might have to wait for a repair (or if warranty not voided but opening case, get them to provide a new HDD and I'll fit it - takes much less time!).

Thanks for the help.
 
If you baught it in Currys in the UK and its faulty within 12 months due to bad manufacturing, they have to replace/fix it or give you your money back. Its the law. Doesnt matter if its discontinued.
 
If you baught it in Currys in the UK and its faulty within 12 months due to bad manufacturing, they have to replace/fix it or give you your money back. Its the law. Doesnt matter if its discontinued.

I know that. Firstly, got it at PC World. They don't have any stock, so they can't exchange or replace. The next available model is 253 miles away, and they can't DHL (move from one store to another), because the drivers have been nicking products. Their repair schedule is 3 weeks behind, so if I put it in for repair, it's gonna be at least 5 weeks. They are unwilling for me to repair it, and for them to reimburse me the cost of a hard drive of similar specification bought from their store. I do not want a refund, as this computer needs to be here and working by Friday, at the absolute latest. It's my sisters and shes going to university with it.

Thanks for the help anyway.
 
Back
Top