Which one is the best system for the money??

allenee2009

New Member
I am really new to custom computers and looking to buy a mid range pre-built gaming computer.
I have looked around a lot and narrowed down to these three custom made computers by other people. Could you guys please help me to choose?

1.AMD Phenom� II X4 940 Quad-Core Black Edition 3.0GHz w/ 8MB Cache
-Asus M4A79 Deluxe w/ DualDDR2 1066, 7.1 Audio, Gigabit Lan, 1394, PCI-E, Quad CrossFireX
- OCZ 600W ModXstream Pro SLI Ready Power Supply
-Sapphire Radeon HD 4770 512MB DDR5 PCI-E w/ Dual DVI, HDTV-Out
-OCZ 4GB PC2-8500 Reaper HPC 4GB Edition Dual Channel DDR2 Kit (2 x 2GB)
-SEAGATE 320GB Barracuda 7200.10 SATA II + Maxtor 250GB
-gaming case with 2 front fans, 1 side fan, 1 top fan and 2 rear fans (black with plexy side and top)
asking for $750

2. AMD Gaming system, with 1.5TB Drive
-Phenom 9500 Quad core Processor
-4GB Crucial Ballistix PC6400
-1.5TB Seagate Barracuda drive
-8800GTS 512MB Vidcard (I think it's a gigabyte)
-MSI K9N2 Platinum SLI motherboard
-22X SATA DVD Burner
-Corsair Power supply
-Silver Case with front LED fans
-Running Windows 7 RC
-Price: $660


3.
-Q6600 Processor, Tested at 3.4, conservatively sitting at 3.2GHz
-4GB OCZ Platinum RAM PC6400
-Asus P5K-SE Motherboard
-Gigabyte 8800GTS 512MB (G92 core)
-500GB Seagate HDD(I can add more if you want more space, up to 4 drives)
-535W Sigma power supply. Quiet and does the job well.
-Vista 64-bit
With the Vidcard at 757/1091 core/mem and CPU at 3.2GHz, scored 14910 in 3Dmark06. Enough to play almost anything at very high settings (unless you're pushing a 30" screen)
Price: $780

4.Case: AeroCool AeroEngine Plus Mid Tower ATX Case - Black
CPU: AMD Phenom X4 (quad core) 9950 Black Edition 3.0 GHZ
Video Card: EVGA Nvidia Geforce 9800 GTX+ Superclocked 512mb
Optical Drive: LG HD DVD player and burner (can't remember speeds but burns fast)
MotherBoard: Asus M3N72-D
Memory: 4GB OCZ DDR2 1066mhz Gold Edition
Harddrive: 500GB 7200 RPM
Netword card: Gaming network card Killer xeno PRO great for online gaming acts as a subprocessor to increase framerates and lower ping on online games.
Power supply: Apevia 750 WATT SLI/Crossfire ready
Sound card: Creative Sound blaster audigy SE 24-Bit Advanced HD sound
Peripherals: 22" LG lcd monitor, LED backlit keyboard and mouse.
Price: 800

p.s btw the prices above are CAD.
 
Last edited:
If you were to rank them...what would be the second best then?
Phenom II (Although i would try to get some G.skill or patriot or mushkin over ocz memory) is the only good option:

Q6600-
Older cpu, not much of a way to upgrade.

Phenom 9500-
Old cpu, runs hot, TLB bug, bad overclocker
POS Power supply
 
Last edited:
I've got G-skill in 2 computers and like it. But I've heard nothing but good things about OCZ? Why the knock?
Well, ive had alot of problems with ocz and their ddr3, and their ddr2 was alright i guess, but ive had issues with that aswell, while with gskill, patriot, and (especially) mushkin ive had pretty much no issues.
 
I would go for choice number 1, second wold be the q6600 build. lol original phenoms not the best lol...
 
It looks like you guys just focus on cpu's. Shouldn't we take other things into consideration as well?
Well, the main reason is the gpu is pretty even between those. The 4770 is roughly similar to the 4850 in performance. The 4850 is about on par with a 9800gtx+ in performance. The 8800gts G92 is a bit slower than a 9800gtx+, even though they use the same core. Which means the gpu in all of these are pretty much even. Another thing to look at is the power supply, the Q6600 has a sigma power supply which is a piece of garbage. The Phenom II based system has an OCZ power supply which is a quality unit.

Question- have you thought about building your own?
 
Well, the main reason is the gpu is pretty even between those. The 4770 is roughly similar to the 4850 in performance. The 4850 is about on par with a 9800gtx+ in performance. The 8800gts G92 is a bit slower than a 9800gtx+, even though they use the same core. Which means the gpu in all of these are pretty much even. Another thing to look at is the power supply, the Q6600 has a sigma power supply which is a piece of garbage. The Phenom II based system has an OCZ power supply which is a quality unit.

Question- have you thought about building your own?

Thanks for the reply.
I have, but it turned out those pre built computers are cheaper than if I were to build one. Like I said, I am not really looking for a high-end gaming computer. I just need something that I can just play games like Crysis on.
 
I added the new system #4 which turns out to be the cheapest with 22" LCD screen.
Any comments on that?

p.s I know phenom II is still the best setup but I have a limited budget. And I wasn't looking for a high end gaming computer either. (Just enough to play Crysis at the high setting)
 
I added the new system #4 which turns out to be the cheapest with 22" LCD screen.
Any comments on that?

p.s I know phenom II is still the best setup but I have a limited budget. And I wasn't looking for a high end gaming computer either. (Just enough to play Crysis at the high setting)
Sorry to tell you but none of those are going to do that, unless your playing at like 1024x768. The fourth one has an apevia power supply, which is also utterly horrible.
 
Back
Top