X1900XT or all in wonder w/ X1900

[wixostrix]

In another thread i decided to go with a X1900XT(http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?item=N82E16814102051) but i also want a tv tunner(from ATI) so would it be better to get the All-in-Wonder with X1900 256MB 256-bit or keep the XT and buy a seperate tunner?

 

[daygowop]

its really up to you because the performance of the x1900 xt is really not significantly better than the all-in-wonder. If i were you I would just go with the all-in-wonder because it saves you some space. just make sure you have room for both the video card and the tv tuner if you decide to buy the tuner separate.

 

[diduknowthat]

Buying a separate TV tuner (especially a good oen) would offer better quality than the all in wonder card.

 

[killer95max]

Buying a separate TV tuner (especially a good oen) would offer better quality than the all in wonder card.

Exactly what he said, plus the video card will be smaller, those AIW are huge!

 

[audiobahn1000]

I have the X1900XT. I like it. It preforms very well. But the fan is loud when it picks up speed.