Are the cables in the HDD cage in the way of the fan in the front? You may wanna try stuffing those extra cables either behind the mobo or behind the CD drive cage.
Mid 60s is pretty high for not overclocking. The dot-in-the-middle technique is more for AMD CPUs since the cooler basically is only touching the CPU. With intel, its a little lower so the way arctic silver recommends is the link I posted. That may be just for that particular thermal paste, but it may apply to all the other ones too.
I would definitely reapply or try a different technique. There's no way you should be getting that high of temps with that massive heatsink. Once you remove the heatsink, you will have to remove the paste using isopropyl alcohol or a thermal paste remover and reapply.