Did I get screwed over (laptop screen question)

whitewater_rob

New Member
I have a Compaq Presario R4000 with the extended warrentee option. I brought it back for repairs for two reasons.

1) plastic casing on cc/dvd disk drive was loose... Conceivably my 'ware and tear' and my fault.

2) LCD screen has 'burn marks' or patches of brighter lighting on my screen. They started with a few, but now I've got like 10 of them. The partern is like oil spilt on a sreen (aka random), with on of the marks 2 inches long (like the oil drop running down a surface)

So the computer came back, and they fixed the cd/dvd drive ( essentially a 3$ piece of plastic). Then they claim the screen was my fault, as a result of one of the three reasons

1).. I took a pen/pointer to my screen and used it as a tablet pc... I definately have never done that

2) grabbing my laptop in one had ( I thought maybe they were right, since I've done that, but my burnmarks are mostly in the center, there is no way my fingers could but pressure on the center of the screen, unless you've got shaq oneils hands)

3) having too many school books in my backpack with my computer... (again textbooks would apply a uniform pressure distribution, my marks are 1/4 inch of width or smaller.

Do #2 and #3 seem like plausible causes? I'm not trying to vent or anything, I just seems like they fix computer/warrentee problems if they are small, then back out if its an expensive thing like an LCD screen.
 
Personaly i would go kick the gut :P. but i have to aggree, it is unlikely for then to just apper. Although, i would think they would fix it. I would just say that you dont do anything bad to your comp. mostly they are nice to you about this. (mostly :P)
 
It doesn't seem unlikely that they were fault of error, but it can also be caused by pressure and the keyboard.... I think that it is pretty hard for that kind of thing to happen because of the build quality or some such.
 
You know... A couple months ago I was laying in bed with my laptop on my chest. It began to slide off so I quickly snatched it...by the screen, thumb on the actual LCD potion) I heard a crack and I was sure I cracked the screen, but I can find no damage(including case cracks). This was probably the worst thing that ever happened to my laptop, yet somehow I got this lighter spot as you're talking about in the upper right edge. Realize this appeared before the above incident...

I guess I'm just not convinced some of these marks don't just appear...
 
Yeah, as a suggestion dont run your laptop with the screen shut and especially dont put pressure on it if the laptop is warm. Obviously dont shut it with anything other than a Microfiber cloth in there.
 
I close my computer screen all the time without having it shut down first, it just goes automatically into standby...but I'm gathering by what you are saying its not the best idea to do this.

-Robbie
 
I close my computer screen all the time without having it shut down first, it just goes automatically into standby...but I'm gathering by what you are saying its not the best idea to do this.

-Robbie

not that i condone this practice but....... do you have contents insurance and if the answer to that is yes, then wouldn't it be a shame if it took a tumble.....accidently......down the stairs !!!!
 
Back
Top