Don't get me started on Caviars. I have another dead Caviar on my desk from a custom built system this morning, not even two years old. I have one in the back seat of my car, brand new, died in 24 hours about a week ago and cost me hours of time. I've repaired a dozen corrupt WD Caviars this week (and funny enough, no other brand). I see a dozen dead or buggered up Caviars each week...and one dead Seagate in the last two years.
Soooo.. You tell me.