I ended up getting the HAF 932 by cooler master.
http://www.frozencpu.com/products/8..._Air_Flow_Full_Tower_Case_RC-932-KKN1-GP.html
There were a few features that sold me on it. For one the 5.25" drive bays have sleds which easily snap in and out. The optical drive rails are built in, with a push button lock, so no more of me losing rails and having to order them from the manufacturer. The PSU mount is adjustable so it fits all sizes of PSUs. It comes stock with all the fans, so you don't have to buy them extra. It allows you to take off the under mounting bracket of a CPU heatsink/fan with out taking the board out of the case via a access hole on the other side of the case. It also has cable routes on the outer bracket of the closed side of the case that allows you to snake your cables through there so they aren't in the way.
I really wanted the Antec P182 (I think that is the model) but they were out of stock on it. The Cooler Master case was only $149.00 and even though it was slightly too big for what I wanted, and it has sections for liquid cooling (which I won't use) the other features and the price were right enough for me.
So, now it is just a matter of waiting for my parts. A lot of my parts had free rush shipping on them, so hopefully that will apply to everything I bought.
I think I will post an update on my blog when I get it, and run some benches stock on XP and Vista maybe (if I have the time) and compare the differences.